Originally, I was just going to get her the baby doll as her Christmas present but my husband proclaimed that she should have lots of presents to open. I can understand (and got to witness) how exciting and fun it is for her to open multiple presents but I had originally resisted because I didn't want her to be too engulfed in the American tradition of mass consumerism and also developing an expectation for lots of presents as she gets older. Besides, I'm frequently buying her things throughout the year anyway so she's hardly living a life of scarcity. I've come to realize that it doesn't matter whether she gets one present or eight presents, usually toys, (e.g., during birthdays), she gets bored of her toys in about two weeks anyway. So it'll be interesting to see how long she will be interested in playing with her baby doll before it becomes old news.
When I was a kid, my mom would take us to a toy store and let us each pick out a toy for Christmas (with a pre-set monetary limit: $20 if I remember right). It was pretty obvious who the present was from. Maybe my brothers and I were old enough by the time we immigrated here to believe in Santa Claus but we never had to be told that Santa Claus was not real. My parents were Buddhists anyway. It also explains why I didn't have a Christmas stocking growing up and got my first one when I spent my first Christmas with my husband. Currently, on our wall, there is a stocking for Scarlett with her name stitched in (made by my husband's mom) a stocking with my husband's name stitched on it (made by my husband's mom from when he was little), and a no-name stocking that my husband bought for me nine years ago.
My husband and I have already started telling Scarlett that the presents were from Santa but is that a good idea? When I told my husband that we should just tell her the presents were from us, he thought I was a scrooge and had no Christmas spirit. But really, is it such an "American" tradition that every kid has to be told this lie, especially in such a diverse community that we live in here in California? Do the immigrant kids at school tell the other kids that Santa Claus isn't real? Or do the Jewish kids really think that their eight Hanukah presents are from Santa? No, and no, probably. So why do we perpetuate this tradition of lying about Santa Claus and having to break the truth later on? I guess we did it because it was how my husband was brought up and even though neither one of us are really affiliated (or interested) in any religion, we just go with the flow. But here's my question to everyone who tells their children that Santa slides down the chimney and puts the presents under the tree: what's so bad about telling your children that you, the parent, gave them those presents?